Appraisal of asymptotic methods in electromagnetic field calculations
The electromagnetic radiation of
antennas in an environment (e.g. fixed to a mast or surrounded by buildings)
is influenced by reflections of surrounding structures and by diffraction
at the edges of these structures. This edge diffraction can be calculated
with asymptotic methods (like Uniform geometrical Theory of Diffraction
(UTD) or Geometrical Theory of Diffraction (GTD)) which assume that the
observer is located many wavelengths away from the edge. When the observer
and the source are situated within a few wavelengths of the edge, the accuracy
of the asymptotics is unclear. Because of the fact that antennas are placed
in the neighbourhood of other objects, the first aim of this contribution
is to get a quantitative idea of this accuracy by studying the simplified
problem of a dipole near a perfectly conducting wedge for which an expression
is available in closed form. The closed-form expression is quite involved.
Hence, a second aim is to find ways for succesfully handling the complicated
closed-form expression nummerically, which is far from trival. This closed-form
expression is derived from the Maxwell equations using the formalism of
Green's functions. This expression consists of an infinite integral over
a summation over a product of Bessel, Hankel and complex exponential functions,
see [1]. The expression has been evaluated using numerical integration
techniques and is compared to the one obtained with asymptotic methods.
The numerical solution of the electric field has been checked for the case
of an axial dipole near a ground plane, which can be calculated using the
image theory [2]. The numerical integration method has been used parallel
with the Uniform geometrical Theory of Diffraction (UTD), see [3], for
different parameter configurations. These parameter configurations consist
of the angle of the wedge, the wavelength and the position of the source
and the observer in cylindrical coordinates. The results were used to appraise
the UTD in the parameter configurations where the UTD is expected to deviate
from the exact solution. The most striking difference occurs when the angle
of the wedge is sharp and both the source and observer are located within
one or two wavelengths of the point of the wedge.
[1] Tai, C.T., Dyadic Green's Functions in Electromagnetic
Theory, second edition, IEEE Press, Piscataway, N.J., 1994.
[2] Balanis, C.A., Antenna Theory, Harper and
Row, New York, 1982.
[3] Kouyoumjian, R.G. and Pathak, P.H., A Uniform
Geometrical Theory of Diffraction for an Edge in a Perfectly Conducting
Surface, Proc. IEEE, vol. 62, No. 11, pp. 1448-1461, 1974.
|